Two decades ago, a key law gave the federal government a pass to ignore bedrock environmental protection laws in the name of border security…
Although the U.S.-Mexico border was established in 1848 via the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo, it existed for most of that time as a boundary largely on paper. The Rio Grande served as a natural barrier in sections, with others occasionally marked with low fencing.
In 2005, Congress passed the Real ID Act, following a recommendation from the 9/11 Commission to create security standards for drivers licenses. In addition, the act gave the executive branch power to waive local, state, and federal laws in service of expediting border wall construction. At the time, the goal was quick construction of a section of border wall near San Diego.
Since then, each subsequent administration has drawn from that part of the Real ID Act to ignore dozens of environmental regulations, like the Endangered Species Act and the Wilderness Protection Act, in favor of border wall operations and construction. Such laws were intended to protect wildlife populations and sensitive habitat by limiting or prohibiting activities that contribute to population decline and landscape degradation and destruction.
When Donald Trump was elected president in 2016, he campaigned with a promise to construct a wall along the U.S.-Mexico border. About 450 miles of new border wall saw construction between 2017-2021, and even more construction is underway following Trump’s reelection in 2024. New border wall construction is permanently reshaping landscapes as crews blast apart rock, mountains, and plant life to make way for the installation of steel bollards, concertina wire, and other fencing materials. In Coronado National Memorial, the final mile of Arizona Trail closed in April to protect park visitors from dynamite blasts underway during wall construction.
"Environmental monitoring related to border wall work is lackluster at best. Whether surveys happen is at the discretion of the Department of Homeland Security, and they tend to be limited in scope and time, resulting in very few environmental mitigations and protections. There are minimal opportunities for public involvement and external accountability measures."
What our cameras saw
Our study with Sky Island Alliance found the border wall already cut wildlife crossings by 86% compared to vehicle barriers alone.
Camera traps along the border have caught deer, mountain lions and coyotes reaching the wall, only to find it impassable. Some smaller animals are still able to pass, though the majority of large animals such as adult black bears are not. A proposed second wall would close the small openings still letting a few through, likely pushing that number even higher.
A More Robust Border Wall Means Fewer Wildlife Crossings
With the border wall in its current form, and additional length being added each day, wildlife in the borderlands face a wide array of impacts to their survival.
A 2024 study by Wildlands Network and the Sky Island Alliance of 100 miles of border wall found that only 9% of wildlife interactions with the wall led to a successful crossing, compared to a 65% success rate when encountering vehicle barriers at the border.
Mountain lions in areas isolated by development and roads in California show signs of genetic inbreeding. A partially open border has allowed some cats to cross into Baja California, allowing for a sharing of genetic information. But with 85% of the border wall in California complete and construction underway to close remaining gaps, southern California’s lions may be cut-off from this source of valuable genetic material for good.
A 2022 study found that as jaguars attempt to reach desert springs north of the border — a key water resource for the species in its northernmost range — border wall infrastructure significantly increases the amount of energy jaguars must use to reach the water. Even smaller wildlife species, like bobcats and badgers, seem hesitant to pass through walls with only 4-inch-wide openings.
In California, a continuous border wall would severely impact the movement and survival of Peninsular bighorn sheep. Our analysis of GPS tracking data shows that the sheep spend roughly half of their time in each country, with prime habitat for raising lambs in the U.S., critical water sources in Mexico, and valuable forage plants spread throughout the borderlands. [306]
Animals of all types and sizes are being impacted daily by the border wall. How significant the impacts are and how we can address them are the critical research questions that lie before us as we aim to find solutions to this crisis.
Watch: This is the Borderlands
Our researchers on the ground are reporting the latest developments in this rapidly changing landscape.